This is a classic said to have a lot of crossover appeal, although it's published as Adult (and I think rightly so.) The main character is a teenager who is, albeit, dead. She was murdered, and she watches from heaven as the cops and her family struggle not only with their emotions, but to find the culprit as well.If it sounds like a morbid read, you're kind of right. Susie Salmon just can't let go of her old life on Earth. She continuously watches her family as they age, and latches on to them, trying to experience life through their eyes.
I don't know how to fully form my opinion on this one. The premise is dark, twisted, and wickedly awesome. I'm just not sure how well it was delivered. For instance, Susie had very little qualms with her actual rape and murder, instead just mostly wishing she were alive again. But, I don't care if you're dead, you'd remember something that traumatic and have struggles over it. And I liked the way heaven was described in the book, but I thought they could have elaborated a lot more. It felt like the book was jumping around, and it didn't fully hold my interest. The writing was meh, the plotting was ick, and probably the only good thing about this was the actual idea.
And there was a very weird occurrence that didn't really match the book near the ending. It happened out of the blue, and was very WTF.
I think I'm being too harsh, because if someone asked me my opinion, I wouldn't say I disliked it completely. I'd say it was "okay". But did it deserve it's acclaim and status? In my opinion, no. Give that same idea to a thousand other authors I could name, and it would turn out better by twentyfold. But as a simple book, by itself & without acclaim, it was okay. I think I expected too much more out of it. And there go my expectations, ruining a book for me yet again. I need to stop believing praise so extremely.








