Sunday, January 3, 2010

Why I Love YA Books

When someone questioned whether I'd continue to read YA as an adult, I instantly remembered writing this nostalgic rant/reasoning, which I posted almost a year ago. My answer is a resounding yes. I intentionally wrote it after a slew of articles questioned the relevance of YA. This post - one I wrote at the very beginning of 2009 - explains exactly why it's relevant. I just thought I'd remind you all:

There's a certain type of magic about being a child. I'm 17 at the moment, so some would still consider that "a child". But I don't. It's smack dab in the middle. From about 13+ - the teen years (and even a bit before then) - you start learning and dealing with tougher issues. You lose some of that believe-anything fantastical kiddish factor, even though you haven't completely loosened your grip. You gain some things, too - it's the age where you start learning who you really are. And "growing up" is a tough process we all go through.

I remember, when I was about seven or eight years old, I was obsessed with butterflies. I wanted my own, as a pet; I wanted one to fly around my head all day, and perch on my hands when it needed a rest. It amazed me to learn that butterflies got their food from the flowers - nectar, I was told. I just thought the two liked each others company. But, as a curious child, I wanted to know what was IN nectar. What was so scrumptious about it, that the butterflies kept coming back for more? When I asked my mom this, she described it as "sugar water". So I got out a cup. I added the water. I poured in the sugar. And I took it outside, set it on a tree stump, and waited. I would sit outside for minutes upon minutes (and that's a lot, considering a child's attention span!) for days on end. Waiting for the butterflies. And for the special one that I knew would become my new pet.

Of course, when they didn't come, I'd drink the yummy sugar water for myself. But that's not the point. I kept believing that those butterflies would come, and I'd be the lucky gal to befriend them.

That youthful belief is why I think I'll always like children's books. And Young Adult. Sure, I know now that I won't be able to have a pet butterfly. But at what point does that change? When do you go from butterfly-loving, sugar-water-drinking child, to a teenager, figuring out your identity? I think this change is one of the hardest things to go through, and it's something you do unconsciously. Being a teen is a ton of guesswork; full of ups and downs and highs and lows. But I think, no matter what age you are, you don't forget your butterfly moments. Or the tough process of slowly letting go and growing up.

So, if you're still reading Children's/Young Adult at an age beyond when you're "supposed" to, and you're ever questioned on that (as a lot of articles have been bringing up lately), you should feel pity for the scoffers, instead of anger. Because, poor them - they've forgotten their butterflies.

20 comments:

  1. An absolutely beautiful story! And great advice! I plan on reading YA and children's books until the day I can no longer read anything!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Awesome AWESOME post! I wrote one similar to this when I did a guest blog at Peace Love & Pat's. (You can read it by clicking here if you'd like.) You definitely have a point! At 19 years old, I'm at the tale end of my teenage years, and I still think this holds true!

    ReplyDelete
  3. you are wonderful. i want to carry this story around in my pocket and throw it at ya naysayers.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Oh wow, I agree. Being grown up, let alone reading about being grown up and grown up issues, can be so boring. I'll always prefer YA fiction just because everything is so exciting (even if it can be horrible) at those ages.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Amazing post. Utterly beautiful. And you said you were having a bad writing day! *scoffs*

    ReplyDelete
  6. What a lovely post. I'm 24 and I LOVE YA books; one of my friends mocks me a lot for it, but I just think she's missing out.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Heeee...sweet story. You should add some butterflies to your blog design to always remind you of your first love. :)

    Even tho I write YA, I hate the distinction between YA and adult, as if the former is somehow a lesser art form than the latter. I also wish it wouldn't get lumped in with "children's" writing as most readers of YA are far more sophisticated than children. I think more readers would choose to read YA fiction if it weren't ghettoized in stores.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I'm 25 and I still love to read YA books. I get that everyone is entittled to their own opinion, but it makes me mad that people are so quick to judge. I read a lot of books and YA books just seem to have this quality about them that I can't really describe. To me someone asking why I still read YA is like critisizing an author that is as older or older than I am for writing it. Anyway, I will grow old and still read YA. :)

    ReplyDelete
  9. Awesome post.... forgotten their butterflies...LOL great line!

    I so agree! I am 42 and love YA. I just really got into it last year and haven't looked back.

    ReplyDelete
  10. This is awesome! :-)

    I'm 31 and I love YA. I get in frequent fights with people on my online book club about it, but mostly I just feel bad for them for being so close-minded.

    Keep those butterflies!

    ReplyDelete
  11. Beautiful post, Chelsea! I love YA, and I don't see myself stopping reading these books for many, many years to come. Or watching TV shows and movies geared at teens, for that matter. Bring on the magic!

    ReplyDelete
  12. I just adore this post! Beautifully said!

    ReplyDelete
  13. I'm 37 and about 90% of what I read is YA. Yes, that's bc I write YA, but I write YA bc I adore this genre. The best stories today are YA and you can do so much with this genre. Writing for teens is a true pleasure and a treat!

    ReplyDelete
  14. Beautiful post! I'm bookmarking this one! :) I'm almost 21 and a sophmore in college and pretty much ONLY ever read YA books! I'm totally like Peter Pan-I never want to grow up! (Especially if it means having to give up my precious YA books and childish enthusiasim! :))

    ~Ella

    ReplyDelete
  15. Lovely, lovely example. I'm 23, and my absolute addiction to and passion for YA is nowhere near its end. Sure, I get strange looks and more than my fair share of condescending pats on the head, but there's something universally relevant and meaningful about YA that just won't let me go!

    ReplyDelete
  16. I was always afraid when I was a little girl that I would stop reading children's books as soon as I was an adult. I'm sort of adultish now, and I still rifle through the books my little sisters get from their school libraries, looking for something good to read. I wish college libraries had shelves full of young adult and children's books.

    ReplyDelete
  17. This is one of the most beautiful and wonderful posts you have ever written.

    It is sad, because they have forgotten their butterflies.

    I'm saving this post to keep forever. I hope you don't mind.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Awww. Thank you, Heather!! :)

    And thanks for sharing all your own stories, guys. I'm glad I'm not the only one who feels this way!

    ReplyDelete
  19. I'm glad I still have my butterfly!

    Moving post, Chelsea. I hope you post more like this :-)

    ReplyDelete
  20. That is a great post, Chelsea. I just recently got into YA. I was one of those "scoffers" who thought YA was the YA of my youth, full of Sweet Valley High and similar fare. Nothing substantial.

    But I learned this year that the YA of today is much more intelligent, much deeper, and has a much broader scope than it used to. I am a newbie fan of YA and I am 30 years old!

    ReplyDelete