Nightshade has gotten a lot of buzz, but it's also gotten a lot of flack because it's a "werewolf book." The main character, Calla, finds herself on the brink of making a new pack with another alpha, Ren. But she meets a human and finds herself questioning everything she's been told about her life.It's funny that what's considered the most popular genre in YA currently - paranormal - also gets the most, in what I've seen, criticism.
I was staying in a hospital when a nurse comes in to check my vitals and sees it sitting on my nightstand, and asks the obligatory: "Oh, is that another Twilight book?" (That's italicized not because it's the name of the book, but because of the nasal-y emphasis it was said with.) He was a nice guy, but I noticed the snark and judgment in his tone. I shrugged my shoulders and read it proudly. I mean, I could have easily put him in place with a Meet the Parents comment, but I was on drugs and much nicer than I usually am. It really, really irks me when people make closed-minded generalizations, though. Not just about the cover of the book, which is only what he saw, but that teens would only be interested in reading Twilight. And the generalization that all YA, or all paranormal, is the same standard.
Because, I mean, this book is good. It's not just that it's entertaining - but for a writer, it's a complete lesson in worldbuilding. Andrea Cremer took a myth that's been done before - werewolves, in this case called Guardians - and made a new history for it. It was completely fascinating the way she set up her world and the relationships in it. The idea that these Guardians had to mate based on their superiors - The Keeper's - choices, was a kind of ancient idea, which matches the ancient lore that this is based on. Arranged marriages were regular in many cultures and even still in effect today, chosen based on the best logical matches for both parties. In the kind of deranged "family" that the wolves are, it's the same way. But, as we all know, if people are repressed enough, there will be rebellion. It's an interesting back-and-forth, these Guardians and their Keepers, and it's incredibly interesting to read. Not just because lore interests me, but because the politics behind these paranormal packs was absolutely enthralling.
It was a very different take, and you could tell the author spent a lot of time building this world. All the characters had distinct personalities, the plot was well-paced, and the bonus creatures were sufficiently creepy. It's a very enjoyable read and it's done well. No, it isn't gourmet literature, but that doesn't mean it deserves an upturned nose. I wouldn't scoff if someone told me they were going to see a pure action movie, like Mission Impossible, so I shouldn't have to deal with snark when there's YA or paranormal in the label. Some of those commercialized action movies surprise you with their plotting and acting, and some of these books will definitely surprise people who go in expecting a simple, light read with no merit. I would definitely give this book to anyone naysaying paranormal because I love proving people wrong.



